News

Section 31aa Update: The Saga Continues

Originally published in the July 30, 2026 issue of School Law Notes.

Buckle up – the State School Aid Act Section 31aa (Section 31aa) roller coaster ride continues! Since our last update, the ride has taken two more turns. The Michigan Supreme Court declined to review the state-court challenge to Section 31aa, bringing that litigation to a close. Meanwhile, the Michigan Legislature continued Section 31aa funding for fiscal year 2026-27 while revising several conditions applicable to student safety funding.

Michigan Supreme Court Declines Review

On June 18, 2026, the Michigan Supreme Court denied the Michigan school plaintiffs’ application for leave to appeal the Michigan Court of Appeals’ April 10, 2026, decision. Because the Supreme Court declined review, the Court of Appeals’ decision is final.

Importantly, the Supreme Court’s order does not resolve the separate federal constitutional challenge to Section 31aa pending in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. The federal case was paused while the state-court litigation proceeded. Following the Supreme Court’s recent order in the state case, the parties to the federal case filed status reports, and school official plaintiffs have argued that the federal court should now address their federal constitutional claims. In short, the state-court litigation has concluded, but Section 31aa remains the subject of pending federal litigation.

Fiscal Year 2026-27 Budget Continues Section 31aa Funding

The fiscal year 2026-27 school aid budget continues Section 31aa funding for student mental health and student safety. While the Legislature made several changes to the statute, it retained the investigation and privilege-waiver provisions that generated significant concern during the 2025-26 fiscal year.

Eligible schools may receive up to $73.53 per pupil for student mental health activities and up to $147.06 per pupil for student safety activities. The investigation and privilege-waiver requirements now apply only to the student safety funding, not the mental health funding. With that, schools seeking student safety funding must still agree that, following a statutory “mass casualty event,” they will:

    • participate in a comprehensive investigation;
    • cooperate with that investigation; and
    • waive privileges held by the school that would otherwise protect certain information from disclosure.

Importantly, the statute clarifies that the privilege waiver only applies to privileges “held by the district.” As the Michigan Court of Appeals explained, and the statutory revision reiterates, acceptance of Section 31aa funding does not require individual employees or officials to waive their own personal privileges. That distinction, however, should not be understood as eliminating potential individual exposure. The school may still be required to produce records within its possession or control, including records containing communications or statements made by individual employees or board members, that otherwise would have been protected by a school-held privilege. As a result, while individuals retain their own personal privileges, statements contained in school records may nevertheless be disclosed during a qualifying investigation, potentially creating exposure for the individuals involved.

For fiscal year 2026-27, the Legislature narrowed the definition of a “mass casualty event.” The term now includes any of the following occurring on school grounds or at a school-sponsored event:

    • an incident resulting in significant physical injuries to not fewer than three individuals. The Legislature now defines “significant physical injury” as “an injury involving a risk of death, significant physical pain, protracted and obvious disfigurement, or a protracted loss or impairment of the function of a bodily member, organ, or mental or sensory faculty;”
    • an incident resulting in two or more fatalities;
    • an incident of such scope that emergency response resources within the jurisdiction are insufficient and assistance from surrounding jurisdictions is required; or
    • an incident resulting in a sudden surge of injured individuals necessitating emergency services.

While the revised definition is narrower than last year’s version, the associated legal risks have not been eliminated.

Although the state-court litigation has concluded, the combination of the pending federal lawsuit and the Legislature’s retention of the investigation and privilege-waiver requirements means that Section 31aa will likely remain an important issue for Michigan schools during the 2026-27 fiscal year. Thrun Law Firm will continue to monitor developments in the pending federal litigation and any additional guidance regarding Section 31aa.